Lessons From Lack of Treatment
Even with highly effective rabies prevention and control programs in place, death from rabies still occurs.3-5
In mid-August of 2021, an 80-year-old man in Illinois woke to find a bat on his neck. The bat was captured and found to be positive for rabies. The man was advised to start postexposure treatment for rabies immediately, but he denied the recommended treatment. Early in September, the man reported neurological symptoms, including neck pain, headache, difficulty controlling his arms, finger numbness, and difficulty speaking. He died before the month was over, with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention confirming the diagnosis of rabies.3
In 2011, a Maryland man received a kidney transplant from a deceased donor who had lived in Florida and North Carolina. In 2013, the Maryland man began experiencing symptoms consistent with rabies, and eventually died from the disease a full year and a half after the kidney transplant. After a detailed medical investigation by the CDC, the source of the Maryland man's disease was determined to be the organ donor, a young man who died of unexplained encephalitis that had been attributed to complications from severe gastroenteritis. The CDC's investigation revealed that both the organ donor and the recipient in Maryland had died of a variant of the rabies virus carried by raccoons.4
Had he known this threat and contacted his local health department or visited the emergency department, he might have been treated with rabies postexposure prophylaxis (PEP) and survived.
Only a short time later, a 52-year-old Missouri man died in September 2014. It was reported that the victim had been infected with a rabies virus variant associated with the tricolored bat. The victim was said to have found bats in his home and at his workplace a month before his symptoms began, and he may have unknowingly sustained a bite.5
In the case of the Maryland death in 2013 associated with the organ donor, better communication between the healthcare provider and the originally exposed patient and his family might have yielded a different outcome.
In the case of the Missouri man who died in 2014, he was presumably not aware of the rabies threat associated with bats, whether a bite is apparent or not. Had he known this threat and contacted his local health department or visited the emergency department, he might have been treated with rabies PEP and survived.
Providers in emergency departments, primary care offices, and pediatric offices need better education about rabies and PEP, as do consumers.
The prevention of human rabies deaths begins with increased awareness and better education among healthcare professionals, public health professionals, and the general public, along with improved screening of organ donors to recognize infectious encephalitis and closer monitoring of transplant recipients.
While human rabies deaths have been significantly reduced over the last 100 years, the most desirable outcome is not a decline but the elimination of human rabies deaths.6